Overview: Shift differentials let Administrators add extra pay for hours worked during a set time window, like +$2.00 an hour from 6:00 PM to 6:00 AM, or +10% on weekends. Buddy Punch adds the extra pay to employee Time Cards, Estimated Pay, the Payroll Export, and Buddy Punch Payroll automatically, starting on the date you pick.
Important! Only Administrators can add or edit shift differentials. Shift differentials are available on the Pro and Advanced plans. They are not available on the Starter plan.
Instructions:
Add a Shift Differential
1. Navigate to the Settings --> Pay Rates page. Scroll down to the Shift Differentials section and click + Add a Shift Differential:
2. Fill in the details for the shift differential:
Name: This is the name that shows on Time Cards and in the Payroll Export, so use something your team will recognize, like Night shift.
Days: Select the days of the week the extra pay applies to.
From and To: Select the time window that earns the extra pay. The window can cross midnight, like 6:00 PM to 6:00 AM, and the hours after midnight count too.
Pay this on time entries: Time entries are hours entered as a total, like 8 hours on Tuesday, with no clock-in or clock-out time. Since Buddy Punch can't tell whether those hours fall inside your time window, check this box to pay the differential on every time entry on the days you selected. Leave it unchecked to pay it only on hours with clock times.
3. To pay the differential for the whole day, like weekend pay on Saturday and Sunday, check the All day box. This sets From and To to 12:00 AM, and time entries on those days earn the extra pay automatically:
4. Finish setting up the differential:
Extra pay: Select + $ per hour to add a flat dollar amount for each hour, or + % of regular rate to add a percentage of the employee's regular pay rate. Then enter the amount.
Who: Select All employees, or limit the differential to specific Locations, Department Codes, or Groups.
Starts on: Select the date the extra pay starts. This can't be earlier than the start of the current pay period, so time that's already been paid never changes.
Active: Leave this checked so the differential starts paying.
5. Click Save. The differential will show in the Shift Differentials list on the Settings --> Pay Rates page, along with when it applies, how it treats time entries, the extra pay amount, who it applies to, and the date it started.
Edit or Turn Off a Shift Differential
1. Navigate to the Settings --> Pay Rates page and click the name of the shift differential you want to edit.
2. Make your changes. Use the Apply from date to choose when the changes take effect:
If you don't pick a date, changes apply from Today.
Pick an earlier date to apply the changes to time already worked. This can't be earlier than the start of the current pay period.
Time before the Apply from date keeps the previous settings.
To only move the date the current settings started, pick a new date without changing anything else.
The date the current settings started is shown next to the Apply from field:
Important! To stop a shift differential, uncheck Active. Shift differentials can't be deleted, but an inactive differential stops adding extra pay and stays saved in case you need it again.
3. Click Save once done.
View Shift Differential Pay on Time Cards
Shift differential pay shows by name in the Extra pay column on employee Time Cards, like +$16.00 Night shift, on each shift's row, in the weekly subtotal, and in the total. Est Pay includes the extra pay:
The Payroll Export in Excel format lists each shift differential by name, with the hours inside its time window and the amount. Shift differential pay is also included in Buddy Punch Payroll.
Note: To see pay amounts on Time Cards, Display pay rates on Time Cards must be checked on the Pay Rates page, and employees need a pay rate on their profile. Learn more in How to Add or Edit Hourly Pay Rates.
How Shift Differential Pay Is Calculated
Every worked minute counts: Every minute worked inside the time window earns the extra pay. Unpaid breaks don't.
Overlapping differentials: If two differentials cover the same hour, the higher one is paid. They don't add together.
Overnight shifts: A window that crosses midnight belongs to the day it starts. For example, a 6:00 PM to 6:00 AM differential with Friday selected covers Friday night into Saturday morning.
Time zones: Time windows follow each employee's time zone. On daylight saving time nights, the minutes actually worked are paid.
Holidays: On a holiday set to Overtime rate, Double time rate, or Custom rate, the differential is multiplied by that rate (1.5x, 2x, or the custom rate). For example, a +$2.00 Night shift differential on an Overtime rate holiday pays +$3.00 an hour. On a Regular pay holiday, the differential is its normal amount. Holiday pay is set on each holiday in Time Off --> Company Calendar.
Overtime: Federal law counts shift differential pay when calculating the overtime rate. In any week an employee earns shift differential pay, Buddy Punch adds an Overtime on extra pay line to their Time Card to cover the difference. If your account uses daily overtime or double time, Buddy Punch also checks each day and pays whichever total is higher.
Closed pay periods: Closed pay periods never change, even if a Time Card in them is recalculated later.
FAQs
Q: Can I delete a shift differential?
A: No. To stop one, edit it and uncheck Active. Pay that was already added to past Time Cards stays the same.
Q: Why didn't a time entry get shift differential pay?
A: Time entries don't have clock-in or clock-out times, so they only earn differentials set to All day, or differentials with Pay this on time entries checked. Edit the differential and check that box to pay it on time entries.
Q: What happens to shift differentials if I change to the Starter or Standard plan?
A: Before you update your plan, you'll see a warning and need to check a box confirming you understand. Once the plan changes, Buddy Punch stops adding shift differential pay right away for the whole current pay period, including days already worked. Pay periods that already ended keep what they paid. Your shift differentials stay saved, and they start again if you move back to a plan that includes them. You're still responsible for paying employees any extra pay they're owed.
Q: Why am I asked to agree to an overtime week notice?
A: If your overtime week starts at a set time instead of midnight (like Monday at 5:00 AM), the Overtime on extra pay line is still calculated in weeks that start at midnight. The first time an Administrator turns on a shift differential, they'll be asked to read and agree to a notice explaining this. Who agreed, and when, is shown in the Shift Differentials section of the Pay Rates page.
Q: Do other payroll export formats include shift differential pay?
A: The Excel Payroll Export and Buddy Punch Payroll include it. Other export formats show a note that they don't include extra pay yet, so you'll want to add those amounts in your payroll provider.





